Did Twitch ban all simps, incels, and virgins from using their service? No, of course not, but calling someone (or in some cases even just saying the words) will get you banned for using them. That’s correct, using racial, sexist, and ableist slurs are fine, but defending yourself by calling the attackers, simps, incels, and virgins are not. These new changes pissed off most of the community though and they weren’t shy to tell Twitch about it. I too had some ideas for how Twitch could implement better ideas, that I shared via Twitter, however since Twitter’s not always easy to read, I will include and expand on them below.
Show where every single view is coming from. If you had this implemented, bunnyhop would have been discovered sooner. On top of this, show where individual chatters are from, were they referred from Twitch or from an external site? Did they come from the browse page? Did they come right from someone else’s stream that posted the link for a hate raid? Did they come from Twitter as part of a hate raid? Tracking where every view is coming from would help track down hate raid and sites like bunnybop sooner.
Ability to ban usernames from chats, including wildcard name bans. Users could set it where Knee* would automatically be banned upon trying to chat. How many times will we have to ban ice_wallow_come before they give up? We could easily ban ice_wallo* and everything that started with that would be banned from chatting in your stream.
The RIAA fee was $200,000 per year in 1999, did it go up that much since then? You could just take $1 or something from every paycheck you give affiliates and partners and put it toward that so we don’t need to worry about DMCA complaints.
This one might be tricky, I am not sure if it is possible from a technical standpoint per user, but allow the option of only chatting on Twitch, so they won’t be able to chat on something like bunnyhop, but if they come to the channel itself they can chat without issue. Theoretically it would be possible, it would just require the proper coding on your part to tell if the parent window is twitch.tv or not. The ability for streamers to turn off all embeds or block out websites that the embed can be on, or if it is technically possible ability to white list domains of where it is able to be embedded (technically this may not be possible at all, I haven’t dealt with embedding content like this in years, since the Myspace days).
Allow different levels of mods. Some mods you might trust to mod your chat, but you wouldn’t want to know your address, some mods you know personally and hang out with at your house. Allow us to make that distinction and then certain mods will be able to see things the others won’t. A multitier mod system would allow us to ban our addresses, emails, real names, parents’ names, etc without worry that a mod could go to moderation options and see all of our banned words and connect the dots.
Allow mods to see something like “this IP address has been banned from your chat 5 times since X date” so we know a troll is going to potentially cause problems.
Let streamers timeout and purge mods without them losing their mod power, sometimes they say something that they shouldn’t, but doesn’t mean it’s something that should mean they lose mod. Also let mods purge their own chats as well as other mods. I’ve seen some instances where a mod will accidentally post a password into chat and then the streamer needs to purge them and give them mod back, which can take away from the creative flow of a stream.
Add an option for videos to be seen only if you’re logged in to a Twitch account, this way if we ban someone from chat, you could turn off video for them and then they won’t be able to logout and keep watching.
We saw what happened with pornhub this week with them removing every nonverified video because of potential child porn. There have been age verification laws pending in the UK for years now with mindgeek (pornhub’s parent company) leading the charge in making the age verification technology. You should do it. Amazon having age verification for free that could be implemented into Twitch and any website allowing alcohol sales, adult vids, etc without having the need to provide an ID to individual sites could be a good game changer for the internet. This technology would mean that a user could submit their ID once, you would be able to verify they are an adult, show them beer, weed, condom ads, have an adult section on Twitch like you have alluded to in the past, and change internet culture forever.
Set clear rules for what is allowed on the rated E, T, and M streams. Mixer had these. Any alcohol, tobacco, excessive cursing, or weed had to be on rated M, you can then use this to determine ad spacing since if it’s for everyone they shouldn’t see beer or condom ads. What would happen if a Nickelodeon Show had beer and condom ads on it? In addition to better ads per rating, allow tags for what ads should not be shown on a stream. It’s in very poor taste to have a recovering alcoholic have beer ads on their stream (yes this happens a lot).
Bring back communities. You added tags, but removed communities. It’s not exclusive, it would be good to be able to search for LGBT+ in the X community playing Dead by Daylight. You want to help out small streamers? That’s how you do it, you add discoverability like that. When it comes to new tags, listen to the community. Trans people are already being harassed on your website, they are banning and moderating their chats just fine, so the excuse of a trans tag would bring more hate is just dumb. Add the damn tag, it’s what the community is specifically asking for, you can go around and around when people say we want to hold you accountable and what does that even mean because it is vague, this is a very clear ask of them, they want a tag. Give them the tag.
Show all games that have gotten streamers DMCA complaints for in game music specifically so we know what games to avoid. You have a list of banned games that will get a user banned for streaming them, why can’t we have a list of games that are getting DMCA complaints?
Ability to turn off affiliate on a stream by stream basis. Sometimes if you are running a charity stream you may not want to get subs and donations and instead want all money to go to charity. This would also allow us to stream to multiple platforms for more exposure for charity. Also allow us to just opt out of the Affiliate Program with the click of a button. I have seen people who try to opt out and never receive a response and are stuck in it because you never got back to them. A cashout and turn it off completely where they won’t be able to join back for X amount of months where they don’t need to contact you at all would solve this.
Allow alt tags on images for improved disability options. You give us limited options on how to use our profiles, but the fact that there is no alt tags for images means we can’t have it look nice and be disability friendly. Mixer gave us full HTML fields to play with, which included the option for alt text on images, making a profile more of our own and less generic, etc. While these wouldn’t necessarily play well with Extensions and the tab profile you have setup, allowing us alt tags could allow us to be inclusive as well as making it pretty.
Links should NOT be clickable by default. If a mod posts it fine, but a random user? Yes, we can turn it off in automod like @DarlingAndDeath said, but new streamers might not know that. At the very least if you don’t want to turn off clickable links by random users, maybe have a warning that says “this is going to another website not associated with Twitch” like @DanMaskedGamer said.
A way to add a text file full of terms to the automod list so that we can just share terms that should be banned. After seeing @xdetune’s tweet about having to add every single variation of the “N” word he could think of, I thought it would be great to just have a list that could be copied and pasted in that could be updated over time when more and more trolls figured out ways around it. Much to my dismay when I went to test this out, I found out you had to add them one by one and you could not do multiples at a time.
Twitch, you said you wanted us to hold you accountable, but when you do dumb stuff and then double down on it, it sends mixed messages. You’re the biggest streaming site in the world, but you aren’t the only one and with Facebook and Youtube figuring out how to do handle some of this, it makes them look better and better.