Batman: The Enemy Within

Batman: The Enemy Within is a point and click adventure game developed and published by Telltale Games and is a sequel to Batman: The TellTale Series. The game was distributed by Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment under its DC Entertainment label. The series deals with Bruce Wayne's second year of being Batman, which means all new villains and some with old foes emerge, both wanting to take out The Batman. Like the first one, it is episodic and released a new episode every few weeks/months. The first episode came out for macOS, PlayStation 4, Windows, Xbox One, Android and iOS. All episodes were released on the Nintendo Switch on October 2, 2018.

Batman: The Enemy Within Gameplay

Batman: The Enemy Within is a narrative-driven adventure game where your choices shape both Bruce Wayne's path and Gotham's future. The gameplay blends investigation and cinematic action sequences, all built around Telltale's branching story structure. Each episode presents moral dilemmas that force you to balance Bruce's public persona with Batman's vigilante responsibilities, often pushing you into situations where neither option feels clean.

Exploration segments let you examine crime scenes, gather clues, and piece together events using Batman's gadgets. Combat is handled through quick-time events and timed reactions, focusing on precision and situational awareness rather than traditional brawling. Social interactions are just as important, with relationship systems that track how characters respond to your choices, especially allies like Alfred, Gordon, and Tiffany, and unpredictable figures like John Doe.

The game evolves based on how you handle alliances, betrayals, and the escalating threat of the Agency and the Pact. Your decisions determine the tone of Batman's methods, the fate of key characters, and ultimately the identity John Doe embraces. The result is a choice-heavy experience where gameplay is driven by tension and the duality of Bruce and Batman.

Hey look, it's Batman!

Batman: The Enemy Within Story

Batman: The Enemy Within begins with the Riddler returning to Gotham after years in hiding, launching a series of violent puzzles that target both criminals and law enforcement. His attacks force Batman, Gordon, and the GCPD into a desperate race to stop him. The confrontation ends with the Riddler's death and with it, an immediate shift in the balance of power. His murder draws the Agency into Gotham and exposes a deeper criminal conspiracy.

One of the things that I thought really worked nicely with this series was the fact that Riddler wasn't new to the scene, he was in it years ago and is much older than Bruce. His added years made him a more complex, harder to catch criminal, then he took out one of Bruce/Batman's most trusted allies, Lucius Fox.

Amanda Waller arrives with her covert task force, claiming jurisdiction over the investigation. She knows more about Bruce, Batman, and the Riddler's past than she should, and her presence destabilizes Batman's relationships with Gordon and the GCPD. Waller's methods are aggressive, manipulative, and often morally questionable, forcing Bruce to navigate a political minefield while trying to maintain trust on both sides.

Riddler's death also reveals the existence of the Pact, a criminal alliance formed by Harley Quinn, Bane, Mr. Freeze, and the Riddler himself. With their leader gone, the Pact becomes unpredictable and dangerous, pursuing a mysterious objective tied to stolen Agency technology. Bruce is pushed into undercover work, infiltrating the group as himself rather than Batman, which creates tension between his two identities and forces him into choices that compromise his usual moral boundaries.

John Doe becomes the emotional core of the story. Riddler's death destabilizes him further, and his growing attachment to Bruce becomes a volatile thread running through the entire season. Depending on how Bruce treats him, John can evolve toward heroism, villainy, or something far more complicated. His relationship with Harley, his desire for belonging, and his fragile sense of identity all collide with Bruce's decisions, making him the most unpredictable element in Gotham.

Meanwhile, Alfred struggles with trauma from previous events, Tiffany Fox becomes entangled in the consequences of her father's death, and Gordon's trust in Batman fractures under Waller's pressure. Every major character is pulled into the fallout from Riddler's death, creating branching paths that reshape alliances, betrayals, and the final confrontation.

Photobombing the Batman selfie with the Joker!

The season builds toward a climax where the truth behind the Pact, the Agency's motives, and John Doe's transformation all collide. Bruce must decide what kind of Batman he is willing to be, and who he's willing to sacrifice, to keep Gotham from collapsing under the weight of competing agendas.

Something that really worked out was Tiffany Fox becoming Batman's sidekick, it was much different than the typical Dick Grayson Robin one, especially when you learn that she murdered the Riddler and you have to make a choice as to whether to train her or not after finding that out. The story was left open and could bring about a sequel at some point, though after so much time, that is doubtful.

Batman: The Enemy Within Achievements

Batman: The Enemy Within FAQs

Is Batman: The Enemy Within on Game Pass?

Batman: The Enemy Within is not on Xbox Game Pass or PC Game Pass, and it is sold outright on the Xbox Store instead. Game Pass catalogs change often, so it is worth checking current availability before buying in case it rotates in later.

Do your choices from Batman: The Telltale Series carry over to The Enemy Within?

Yes. The Enemy Within reads your save from the first season and reflects earlier decisions, including who survived and how relationships with Gordon and others were left. Starting fresh without a season one save is possible, and the game fills in default choices, but importing the original playthrough makes the continuity land harder.

Does John Doe become the Joker in The Enemy Within?

John Doe is the still-forming Joker throughout the season, and the finale determines which version he becomes. Depending on how Bruce treats him across the episodes, he emerges as either a would-be hero (the "Vigilante" path) or a full villain (the "Villain" path), and the two endings play out as almost entirely different final episodes.

What are the different endings in Batman: The Enemy Within?

Episode 5, Same Stitch, splits into two dramatically different versions based on your relationship with John Doe. One sends him toward a twisted vigilante partnership with Batman, the other toward the murderous Joker attacking Gotham. Several other outcomes shift with earlier choices, including Alfred's fate, whether Bruce keeps being Batman, and how the confrontation with Harley Quinn resolves.

Should you train Tiffany Fox after learning she killed the Riddler?

Late in the season Bruce discovers Tiffany Fox murdered the Riddler to avenge her father, and the game gives a choice about whether to bring her in as an ally afterward. There is no strictly correct answer, it is a character decision, and it shapes how you view her turn as a Batman sidekick rather than the usual Dick Grayson Robin dynamic.

How long is Batman: The Enemy Within?

The full five-episode season runs roughly five to ten hours depending on how much you sit with the dialogue choices, and each episode takes about one to two hours. It is a single-player, story-driven experience with no combat beyond quick-time events.

Is Batman: The Enemy Within a sequel to the first Telltale Batman?

Yes. It is the direct sequel to 2016's Batman: The Telltale Series, continuing the same Bruce Wayne and the same Gotham. Playing the first season first is not required, but it deepens the payoff since several relationships and consequences carry forward.